Thinking about realization is procrastinating

It’s possible to think about anything. You can even think about the fact that realization can occur only when you are aware of something other than thinking.

It can be useful to think a little bit about a few ideas related to realization. The idea I just mentioned is an example. It’s useful to know that realization can occur only when you’re unaware of thoughts, but it’s only useful if you apply the idea by making an effort to stop being aware of thoughts.

If instead you spend time thinking about the idea, you are doing the opposite of applying it. If your goal is realization, you are wasting your time. You are procrastinating. You are postponing realization.

Thinking is a kind of pathological meditation. Like most meditation, it’s a kind of practice, but you are practicing being unconscious and unaware of yourself.

This is true even if you’re thinking about realization.

This is true even if you’re thinking true thoughts.

This is true even if your thoughts are profound wisdom.

If you want realization, the productive, effectual, fruitful reaction to thoughts of profound wisdom is Ramana’s advice, “Ask to whom the thoughts appear.” He means become aware of yourself instead of the profound wisdom. This advice applies to all thoughts whether true or false and whether profound or trivial.

It’s the activity of thinking, not the nature of the thoughts, that’s the problem.

What I say here about thinking also applies to reading and writing. People sometimes read and write essays about the process of realization and the insights it brings and the metaphysics that have been invented to explain it. If you want to do that for fun, fine. Just be clear that if your goal is realization you are wasting your time.

Realization can occur only when you remain conscious while you look away from thoughts.

The goal is to be aware of something that isn’t mental activity. How can thinking about ideas take you to that goal? The activity of thinking about ideas is the opposite of the goal.

The goal is direct experience. There’s no thinking in it. It’s pure knowing. You cannot have that experience while you’re absorbed in thoughts. You cannot make progress toward that experience by thinking.

Years ago someone wrote to me asking if certain ideas about realization were true. I wrote back that it’s not important whether they are true. The important thing is that they are thoughts, and thoughts are barriers to realization.

He was an intelligent man but he couldn’t grasp what I was saying. He couldn’t hear it. In a series of emails I kept stating in different ways that the activity of thinking is the barrier, not the truth or falsity of thoughts, but no matter what I wrote, he replied, “I don’t understand what you’re saying. I can’t figure out whether you think idea XYZ is true or not.”

6 thoughts to “Thinking about realization is procrastinating”

  1. Well said and right to the point!

    This is THE issue for 99% of people if not 100, and the realization that the medium (language, conceptual thought) in which the conversation around awakening happens is itself the obstacle is a huge first step. The problem then seems to be that very few people actually step off the carousel of mind often enough to make that way of being their new home base, so to speak, and thus they just talk about realization instead.

    Of course, we have to use language to communicate these things, but it’s always a good to remember that it’s ideally a thorn to remove a thorn first and foremost.

  2. Thanks Ben.

    I like your use of “medium”. As I wrote the article I remembered a bestselling book from my childhood in the US called “The Medium is the Message.”

    Do you think many people find it difficult or impossible to grasp the idea that realization and thinking are different? Some people, maybe, give lip service to the idea but spend a huge amount of time reading spiritual books and thinking about them.

    1. Yes! Marshall McLuhan. We had his name drilled into our minds during comm studies in college.

      I do think that people struggle to differentiate between conceptual thought and actual reality, perhaps unsurprisingly because they spend most of their waking life in thought. They might intellectually understand that the map is not the territory, but they still live in the map world 99% of the time and that is precisely the reason they’ve “overlooked” the looker.

      An analogy that I’ve heard used before is that of a virus. It’s a bit extreme, but I think it has its merits.

      Self awareness, transcendence of mind, is the antidote to the “virus” of incessant thought.

      However, the antidote must be explained / administered via the same pathway that the
      virus was introduced – that is, we use words to share the teaching. (Big caveat for Ramana who I believe understood this clearly and thus considered silence to be the highest form of the teaching, as it’s unable to be corrupted and used for the sole purpose of continued mental proliferation.) But once the teaching is understood, it’s meant to be applied, self-attention must actually happen – lest it become yet another interesting philosophical idea to talk about at dinner parties.

      This virus, not wanting to die, will do everything in it’s power to keep the thought process operating, replicating. One can engage with or debate the merits of the teaching, even regularly go to discuss the teaching with others, and the thought process will simply continue, only with a “more important” purpose. However, the “virus” cares not what is being thought; as long as the thought process is continuing to go on, then there is no problem of its own dissolution.

      A snippet of a quote by Peter Brown I’ve always loved:

      “Leave the realm of the describable! It doesn’t exist!
You define your problems into existence, as well as their hoped-for solutions,
thus creating an apparent difficult, limited reality, where none exists whatsoever.
      This actual, present condition is absolutely inconceivable;
ANY way you hold it to be with your descriptions and ideas
does not actually exist, and cannot in actuality limit or entrap you.
      Your imagined un-realization, confusion, spiritual obscuration,
as well as the imagined enlightenment that you hope for as its solution,
DO NOT EXIST! They are defined into apparent existence
by your imagination.
      This actual condition can be clearly known as it is,
but not if it is held to be this or that
in imagination.”

  3. Yeah. I agree. I’m amazed sometimes that I created a blog that attracts such knowledgeable intelligent comments.

    We seem to have driven everyone away. I guess raining on people’s meditation robes will do that.

    I think the virus metaphor is great except virus sounds like thoughts are invaders of our natural healthy state.. You were talking about words to share teachings but I’m about to talk about compulsive thoughts, so maybe I’m changing the subject.

    I’ve come to believe that compulsive thinking is the natural default function of the brain. IT was created by natural selection for animals much simpler than us. The purpose is for the brain to rehearse (simulate) avoidance of mistakes that happened in the past and accomplishment of desired goals in the future. The thoughts are nauseatingly repetitive because they are rehearsals. They carry a heavy, suffocating emotional weight because that’s how the brain compels us to act.

    But still, virus is a great metaphor. Especially since I probably just switched away from what you said. Just about every interesting metaphor is misleading in some respect or other. Like you say, or the Polish guy whose name i can never remember said, the map is not the territory.

    I think the examples in the Brown quote are true (irony itended) but I think generalizing them as everything describable is non-existent goes too far. But maybe this depends on how we define “existent”.which I think is sometimes an implicit ambiguity in these kinds of conversations.

  4. Excellent article Freddie and equally excellent responses from Ben & yourself. It’s so true: I “think”(!) at some point on the journey, the mind becomes “aware”(!) that one is trying to destroy it and hence it tries to trick us into reading, watching, thinking, debating etc about this topic. As Bhagavan Ramana said “practice is the only way”. Sigh, if it were only that easy, a lot of us would be happy!!
    Have a great one!

    1. Thanks Partha. You’ve got a lot of company with the idea that the mind fights to preserve its existence. Saradamma comes to mind as described in No Mind — I am the Self. Also Michael Langford’s The Direct Means to Eternal Bliss. My experience has been different. It seems to me the mind is inert, like Ramana said, and it has no self-interest. It’s not really conscious. It’s like an AI.

      I think this becomes apparent when we manage to stay conscious long enough to observe what it feels like. Ourself in a conscious state is very obviously the only part of the mind that can care about anything including its existence, it seems to me. The difficulty, I think, is that the brain is designed by natural selection to lapse into repetitive rumination whenever it’s not thinking of something else. This mechanism is very hard to resist by willpower. When this kind of rumination starts, we lose consciousness to some extent. I think it’s a mechanical, built-in feature of the brain.

      I think this is why people find it easier to think than do the practice. When we think, we’re going along with the brain’s built-in default tendency to think. When we do the practice for real, we’re struggling against that tendency.

      On practice, for me it was frustrating for a long time. For years it didn’t get easier or more appealing. In retrospect I think the main problem was that when I tried to be aware of myself, I never got beyond awareness of various mental activities. I think Ramana’s quoted somewhere in Talks saying something like, “Really vichara begins only when we get off the thought waves.” Maybe he meant something like what I just said.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *